Pete, Jo, and Weird Guy take the night to reflect on their life choices. Meanwhile, Sidney and Warren are cruising on their love– but not without a brief pit stop first.
The gang reconnects for their Sophomore year in college after a hectic summer. Jo helps Pete deal with difficult news while Warren and Lars find that there is such a thing as taking the joke too far.
Weird Guy and Jo find themselves in a strange predicament while everyone else deals with the stresses of finals week.
Pete deals with the uncomfortable Jess and Jenny situation the best way he knows how– and Jo is caught in the middle. Sidney is struggling to handle the stress of dead week, and Warren and Lars team up to find ways to distract her.
Pete runs into an unexpected obstacle while planning his day. Meanwhile, Lars, Warren, and Sidney set out to decipher Jo’s mysterious life.
Pete is excited to be finally moving on past his ex-girlfriend, Jess, and plans a dinner date for Jenny. Meanwhile, Jo challenges Warren to a battle of wits– with a specific prize.
Lars is in a frenzy to clean the dorm before his mother arrives for a visit. Meanwhile, Sidney is excited to hear that a famous motivational speaker is coming, and she pressures everyone else to go.
Pete and the crew find themselves having to disprove their eerie similarities to Weird Guy– by betting that they can last through a party until the end.
Sidney prepares frantically for a big night while Jo and Warren offer words of advice. Meanwhile, Pete finds a disturbing development in his mailbox and turns to Lars for support.
When Pete has to study for a major quiz coming up, the gang decides to help him by going to the library– but there get more than they bargained for.