Policy 3006: Staff Employee Grievance Process

Category: Human Resources
Subcategory: Rights & Responsibilities
Covered Individuals: Benefit-Eligible Staff Employees
Responsible Executive: Vice President and Chief of Staff
Policy Custodian: Office of Human Resources, Sr. Associate Vice President of Human Resources
Last Revised: 2026/11/06
Previous USU Policy Number: 325
Download the PDF File for Policy 3006

3006.1 PURPOSE AND SCOPE

This Policy outlines the formal review process for benefit-eligible staff employees to contest certain employment actions. Utah State University (USU) strives to resolve concerns at the lowest appropriate level, address issues promptly, and apply policies fairly and consistently. All USU employees should be treated respectfully and equitably (See USU Policy 3002: Respectful Workplace).

The grievance process described in this Policy covers contested Demotions and Terminations, as defined in this Policy. The process for contesting other disciplinary actions is handled through the escalated review process outlined in USU Policy 3001: Setting Expectations and Managing Performance.

Employment concerns not expressly covered under this Policy and related to discrimination or sexual misconduct will be referred to the Civil Rights & Title IX Office for processing. However, findings from their processes that result in Demotion or Termination may be grieved under this policy.

Likewise, if a Grievance raises issues related to safety concerns, respectful workplace, Environmental Health and Safety (EHS), or other compliance areas, the Office of Human Resources (HR) will refer those issues to the appropriate University office for review and handling. HR may pause or close a Grievance if the contested action falls outside the scope of this Policy or is more appropriately addressed through another University office, policy, or process.

3006.2 POLICY

2.1 General Principles Governing Grievance Process

  1. Employees are expected to raise general employment concerns promptly. Employees should first attempt to resolve concerns informally with their immediate supervisor or the next higher level of supervision. (See USU Policy 3001: Setting Expectations and Managing Performance and USU Policy 3002: Respectful Workplace).

  2. Employees are expected to participate in the grievance process in good faith through honest and timely process engagement, providing accurate information, and cooperation. Employees must not misuse the grievance process by filing false claims or intentionally delaying the grievance process.

  3. The grievance process is not intended to replace day-to-day management, performance management, or supervisory decision making and does not limit or restrict a supervisor’s authority to address performance, misconduct, or other workplace-related concerns.

  4. USU may make operational and personnel decisions, as long as such decisions are not Arbitrary or Capricious and follow applicable policies and laws.

  5. Utah State University prohibits retaliation against any member of the USU community who, in good faith, files a grievance, raises concerns, seeks advice or assistance, participates in a workplace review or investigation, or otherwise engages in protected activity under University Policy.

2.2 Eligibility and Filing Requirements

2.2.1 Eligibility

Benefit-eligible staff employees are able to file Grievances under this Policy. This Policy does not apply to at-will personnel or benefit-eligible staff employees who are still in their introductory period of employment (See USU Policy 3305: Employment-at-Will and USU Policy 3307: Introductory Period of Employment). Faculty may file grievances in accordance with USU Policy 4006: Academic Due Process: Sanctions and Hearing Procedures.

2.2.2  Filing Requirements

To file a Grievance under this Policy, the staff employee must submit written documentation to the Senior Associate Vice President of Human Resources within 10 (ten) business days of the contested action. The Grievance documentation should include, if available, the following:

  • a description of the action(s) and date of the action(s) being challenged;
  • a description of any informal efforts attempted to resolve the action, including supervisory responses;
  • the specific policy or procedure allegedly violated; and
  • the requested outcome.

2.3 Initial Review

2.3.1 Review by the Senior Associate Vice President of Human Resources

The Senior Associate Vice President of Human Resources (Sr. AVP of HR) or designee will determine if the Grievance:

  • falls within the scope of this Policy;
  • meets filing requirements;
  • needs to be referred to another office (see Section 3006.1);
  • will be dismissed; or
  • will proceed under the grievance process.

2.4 The Grievance Process

2.4.1 Grievance Hearing

Grievances contesting Demotion or Termination will be addressed through a Grievance Hearing, wherein a Grievance Hearing Committee will determine whether the contested action was Arbitrary or Capricious.

2.4.2 General Grievance Hearing Procedures

This section outlines the general principles that govern a Grievance Hearing. For detailed hearing procedures, see 3006-PR1: Staff Grievance Hearing Procedures.

Grievance Hearings will:

  • Be conducted by a Grievance Hearing Committee.
  • Allow each party to present relevant information and evidence.
  • Require all testimony at a Grievance Hearing to be given under oath.
  • Be conducted in a manner that promotes fairness, impartiality, and efficiency.
  • Require all parties to comply with the deadlines set forth in 3006-PR1: Staff Grievance Hearing Procedures.
  • Not be postponed or continued due to unreasonable scheduling conflicts, and grievants are expected to make reasonable efforts to be available as scheduled. Extensions may only be approved by the Office of Human Resources in consultation with the Office of General Counsel and will only be permitted when supported by documented Extenuating Circumstances.

2.4.3 Important Limitations

Hearings are not delayed due to the grievant’s involvement, initiation, or participation in other pending University processes.

If allegations related to discrimination, sexual misconduct, or other issues not covered by this Policy arise at any point during the grievance process, those allegations will not be addressed with the Grievance Hearing Committee and instead will be referred to the appropriate University office for review and handling (See Section 3006.1).

2.5 Filing Deadline

A benefit-eligible staff employee must file the Grievance within 10 (ten) business days of the contested employment action. For more information on Grievance Process deadlines, see 3006-PR1: Staff Grievance Hearing Procedures.

2.6 Standard of Review

All Grievance decisions referenced in this Policy use the following Arbitrary and Capricious Standard:

Arbitrary and capricious means doing something according to one's will or whim (as in a sudden unpredictable change). An action or decision is arbitrary if it is not supported by logic or the necessary facts, or if it is made in the absence of decision-making criteria consistent with USU policy and procedures. An action or decision is capricious if it is adopted without thought or reason or is irrational.

Disagreement with a decision does not mean the action was Arbitrary or Capricious. A contested action will only be reversed if it is found to be Arbitrary and Capricious. Otherwise, the contested action or decision will stand.

The staff employee grieving the contested action bears the burden of proof.

2.7 Outcomes

The only available outcome under this grievance process is the reversal of the action, resulting in reinstatement to the same level and conditions of employment and remediation as allowed under applicable law.  Alternative outcomes are not available through this grievance process.

2.8 Final Decision

Following the Grievance Hearing, the Grievance Hearing Committee will prepare and submit its recommendation to the President. The President will provide a decision within 10 business days. The President’s decision will be final and binding. For additional details regarding this process, see 3006-PR1: Staff Grievance Hearing Procedures.

3006.3 RESPONSIBILITIES

3.1 Supervisors

  • Set expectations with employees in accordance with USU Policy 3001: Setting Expectations and Managing Performance.
  • Work to resolve employee performance issues or concerns at the lowest level in a fair and equitable manner.
  • Participate in providing relevant information during the grievance process when all informal efforts have not resolved the issue(s).

3.2 Office of Human Resources

  • Support supervisors and employees during performance management efforts.
  • Receive grievances from eligible employees, review for applicability, and administer and process grievances in accordance with established policy and procedures.

3.3 Grievance Hearing Committee

  • Review applicable grievances.
  • Conduct fair and impartial hearings ensuring respect and equity in the process.
  • Consult with the Office of General Counsel and Office of Human Resources as needed to clarify policy or procedural questions.
  • Issue a determination to the President for final review.

3.4 Employees

  • Coordinate with supervisors as part of performance expectations setting processes.
  • Work to resolve concerns, questions, or issues quickly and informally with supervisors where possible.
  • When choosing to file a grievance, file timely and participate fully in the process with Human Resources and the Grievance Hearing Committee in accordance with established policy and procedures.  

3006.4 REFERENCES

3006.5 RELATED USU POLICIES

3006.6 DEFINITIONS

  • Arbitrary and Capricious Standard. Means doing something according to one’s will or whim (as in sudden, unpredictable change). An action or decision is arbitrary if it is not supported by logic or the necessary facts, or it is made in the absence of decision-making criteria consistent with USU policy and procedures. An action or decision is capricious if it is adopted without thought or reason, or is irrational.

  • Demotion. A disciplinary action resulting in a reduction of a staff employee’s current actual wage.

  • Extenuating Circumstances. Documented and compelling reasons outside a party’s control that justify deviation from established timelines.

  • Grievance. A written request for review of a contested employment action limited to Demotion or Termination as defined under this policy.

  • Grievance Hearing. Review conducted by a Grievance Hearing Committee. Available for Grievances challenging a Demotion or Termination.

  • Termination. For the purpose of this Policy, a dismissal or a reduction in force (as defined in USU Policy 3309: Reduction in Force) of a USHE (Utah Systems of Higher Education) institution benefit-eligible staff employee.

Information below is not included as part of the contents of the official policy. It is provided only as a convenience for readers/users and may be changed at any time by persons authorized by the President, subject to review by the USU Policy Committee.

RESOURCES

Procedures

Contacts

  • Doug Bullock
    Sr. Associate Vice President of Human Resources

POLICY HISTORY

Original issue date: 1997/01/24
Last review date: 2026/11/06
Next scheduled review date: 2029/06/01
Previous revision dates: 1997/01/24; 2010/03/26; 2022/10/14